Is it right to mix religion and healthcare?
28 June 2009 at 14:15 | In Health, Religion | 5 CommentsThe BBC are asking whether it is right to mix religion and healthcare. It comes off the back of a story detailing how doctors are demanding that NHS staff be given a right to discuss spiritual issues with patients as well as being allowed to offer to pray for them.
For those who have faith and a religion the spiritual aspect to their life can almost be as important as taking the medication and treatment provided by doctors. However, should doctors and nurses be involved in that spiritual side? I’d suggest not. The chaplaincy systems operated within the NHS are where the spiritual aspect of getting better are rightly concentrated. Having priests, ministers, pastors, imams (or whatever they are called by the patient) available to come and pray for/with, meditate and talk with patients is a very good idea and can be of great comfort to the patient. I know that when I was in hospital recently that the visits made by a few of the church elders and one of the pastors was very comforting and helpful.
Doctors, nurses and church leaders are all specialist in their own areas and as such should be left to do the job that they do. I don’t know about other faiths, but certainly in Christianity one does not choose to become a church leader, but rather is called to be one. They are specially chosen by God to do the job that they do and this makes them much better equipped to do the job.
I remember reading a story in a book where a junior doctor was telling about the time when he called a priest in for a dying patient who was all on his own. The patient had indicated in their patient records that they were a catholic. The patient died that night, but he did not die alone. The priest sat with him until the end, praying for him and such like. No doctor or nurse could act in this way – the just don’t have the time!
What I am trying to say is that faith has a place in medicine for those who believe in a God, but to mix them together is not the best idea in the world. The doctor-patient relationship works because of the distance between doctor and patient, yes there may be a relationship and/or rapport built up over a long period of time, but it is quite different to the sort of relationship you start entering into with prayer. Prayer is deeply spiritual and I think that the spiritual bond created between doctor and patient were a doctor to pray with a patient would be counter-productive.
Does anyone have any thoughts or opinions?
Boring Update
26 June 2009 at 23:45 | In Personal, Random | Leave a CommentOkay,
It’s been a while since I have blogged, so I thought it would be time for a quick update.
I’m still having seizures and it is still annoying me. I’m still under investigation and I’m due for another blood test on Tuesday morning – this time I have to fast before. This has come off the back of a number of symptoms:
- Extreme thirst
- Being constantly tired
- Needing the toilet more than usual
- Some very low BMs (usually following a seizure). Lowest reading so far as been 2.2
While I have not had any high BM readings it doesn’t mean that I am not suffering from episodes of abnormally high blood sugar, so, coupled with a history of diabetes in my family the doctors are going to investigate this as being a possibility.
It does make sense that low blood sugar is a trigger for the seizures I am having as when my BM has been taken following a seizure it has been quite low, but then again the two could be completely unrelated!
I am starting to prepare for the two re-sits I have which I am not looking forward to, there is a lot to revise for the two exams and I really just want them over so that I can finally progress into my third year!
Other than that life has been very boring, as you have probably gathered from my twitter updates. I have some things that I hope to blog about, and hope to do so on Sunday!
Nightjack
16 June 2009 at 23:28 | In Civil Law, Civil Liberties, English Law | 1 CommentI used to link to a blog called Nightjack. It was written by a, then, anonymous Detective Constable and was about his working life as a DC. I even once published one of his posts on my blog. However, in a case setting legal precedent, The Times has been allowed to reveal who this officer is and it has transpired that the officer, DC Richard Horton, has been issued with a written warning by his force.
The paper reports that many of his posts could be traced back to specific prosecutions. However, that in itself wouldn’t be an issue as much of the information about a case becomes public knowledge throughout the process and by the time the verdict has been delivered everything (or just about) is in the public domain. So, really, as long as the information wouldn’t have been with held by the court, was breaching injunctions or was released (and tracable) at an inapropriate time I fail to see where the issue is (and the paper certainly does not make this clear).
The legal precedent set effectively means that every blogger writing under a pseudonym, like I do, is at risk of having their identity revealed at any time and has little protection under the law. Some food for thought about exactly what we blog about.
Guest Post
16 June 2009 at 23:16 | In Politics, Random | Leave a CommentI was invited to write an article for Huliq News and decided to write about the rule of law in relation to the MPs expenses row that has been happening here in the UK. I will probably contribute to there again in the future.
The article I wrote can be read here
Emotionally Challenging Drama
14 June 2009 at 22:03 | In Counselling Experiences | 1 CommentI’ve been meaning to write this post for a while now; it’s about my last shift at my voluntary job with a national children’s charity. I only took 6 calls over the 4 hours I was there; which sounds a lot, but depending on the shift you can easily answer the phone over 30 times in 4 hours! It was a really stressful shift and it still plays on my mind just now – weeks after it happened. Out of the 6 calls there were 2 breaches and 3 referrals, which is a lot (we don’t usually do that many in a month, let alone one day!).
The first person who I spoke to was a young girl (early teens) who had lost her mother about 3 months previous in a car accident. The whole family was in the car at the time of the fatal crash and dad was driving the car at the time. Her mother was about 6 months pregnant at the time of the crash, and despite the best efforts of the medical team the unborn child also died. To top it all off the caller’s dad had taken it really badly and had turned to alcohol which was having a huge effect on the young person. Being in a car accident where your mum and unborn sibling die and your dad becoming an alcoholic. This is the sort of call that gets all your emotions racing, a young person in such an awful situation, coming to terms with the death of their mum and watching their father ruin his life with alcohol. As far as the caller was aware the father was not seeking any medical help for PTSD, depression etc. So after spending a good 40 minutes or so talking to her we came to a conclusion that she was going to speak to her own GP or a teacher at school about the mess that was her home life. I hope that she did and hope that she gets the help and support that not only she needs, but her dad needs as well.
The second call I took was for an older teenager who had been sexually abused over a period of 5 or so years by his step-father. He told me that he had taken 40 paracetamol tablets and was just waiting to die. I conducted my risk assessment and deemed him as being high risk, my supervisor agreed. I was in the process of trying to get him to allow us to phone an ambulance for him when the one thing worse than the caller hanging up in this situation happened – the line was still connected, but there was no response from the caller. My supervisor rushed to the CSM who agreed very quickly to a breach and within 5 minutes my supervisor was on the phone to the police and BT to get the call traced. We stayed on the line until it went completely dead. We eventually got feedback about this called and it was the worst possible news, but what we expected. The call was successfully traced, but the caller had died. I was the last person this person ever spoke to and he probably died while I was on the phone to him. We doubt the quantity of paracetamol he took, but it was certainly enough to make sure that he died. His last audible word was “help”. Just thinking about it upsets me; this will stay with me for a very long time I suspect.
My third caller was a young lad (early teens) who was being sexually abused by this uncle and a number of his uncle’s friends. This had been going on for about three years. He wanted to do something about it, but was far too scared to contact the police or social services on his own. With our help he spoke to a very nice and helpful social worker (a rarity, especially considering this was outside of officer ours).
My fourth call of the shift was from a young girl who was being physically and mentally abused. From what she was saying her self-confidence and self-respect were non-existent. She had been drained of everything and was very depressed. She self-harmed as a result and was making plans for suicide. I did a risk assessment and deemed her as high risk. With a little bit of encouragement she agreed to allow us to get social services involved. This social worker was not that helpful and was doing all the usual things to try and put it off until 9am on Monday. However, this girl was at serious risk and the couple of days it was until Monday could have lead to a serious or even fatal injury. We couldn’t have social services shirking their responsibility, so we faxed the details to them meaning the social worker had no option other than to deal with it there and then. We also told them we would report it to the police as a way of doubly making sure that something was being done (although we didn’t actually report it to the police as the young person wouldn’t let us and as social services were now involved there were no grounds to breach confidentiality to the police).
My fifth call was from a young person who is a self harmer and had slit his wrists whilst cutting himself. His description suggested that he was losing a lot of blood. Out of the wounds and that he could potentially have very nasty arterial injury. He was also becoming very drowsy. So, as the young person’s life was at risk and he wouldn’t agree to an ambulance the decision was taken to breach the call to the police and BT in the hope that an ambulance would get there in time. We never got any feedback. I didn’t have an opportunity to discuss with him the reasons behind his self harming, but through my experience I can have a good guess at it.
My final call ended up being a referral to the ambulance service. This was an unusual call. A teenager of around the 15 – 17 category called us terrified. He and his younger brother had been left alone for a couple of hours to whilst their parent’s went to IKEA. The caller’s younger brother had somehow managed to get a hold of his father’s drill and had drilled a hole in his leg. The caller asked us if we could phone an ambulance for him, he gave us all the details and armed with this we held a conference call with the dispatcher, the young person and us to get an ambulance to the young person. We ended the call leaving the young person on the phone with the dispatcher once we had heard that an ambulance had been dispatched. We did get feedback from this call and the injury wasn’t as bad as the young person had made us believe, but I suspect the exaggeration was not malicious and came more from the fear of what his parent’s would say when the hospital called them away from their shopping trip.
My shifts are usually eventful and supervisors dread working with me as they know I attract calls such as the above every time I am there, but never usually so many serious calls requiring referrals and breaches. We were there for a long time doing the paperwork, paying particular attention to the ones that have the potential to go to court or there be a police investigation so that should we have to remember what happened we had enough information to do just that. I live up to my name of being a drama magnet. While I was getting all of these high drama calls everyone around me was getting the usual rubbish, I was stressed to the limit and my emotions were shot to bits. However, I left that shift thinking that I had done a lot of good work that day.
I wasn’t long back from a break from my voluntary work after a very hard shift and I am on another one now because of that shift. You really do need time to get over calls like those, especially so many in one shift and especially with the outcome of the second call.
Petition for a UK Constitution
12 June 2009 at 19:44 | In Politics | Leave a CommentUPDATED WITH THE CORRECT LINK 13/06/2009 16:51
Those of you who read my blog regularly will know that I am very keen on the UK having a written constitution to help keep praliament in check and establish a proper balance of power.
I came accross this petition on the downing street website and will sign it at some point in the next few days; I encourage you all to sign it to and for you to pass it onto your friends and family to sign.
The URL of the petition is http://petitions.number10.gov.uk/uk-constitution/
Angry!
11 June 2009 at 19:13 | In Personal, Rant | 3 CommentsI am fuming! I have just found out that my totally incompetent manager has hit a new low. He has been divulging personal and confidential information about me to individuals who have absolutely no need to know this information (i.e. people below me in work and other managers who have no need to know). Not only that but he has been spreading lies about me (and the stuff he is saying is serious as it amounts to serious misconduct what I’ve allegedly done).
He will not know what has hit him when I next see him! I may even take out a formal grievance – plenty of people to give statements to senior management as to what he has divulged.
Canada part two coming soon!
Canada Trip – Part One
6 June 2009 at 15:02 | In Canada 2009, Personal, Random | Leave a CommentSo, I’m back from my trip to Canada and here is the first part of my “trip report”. We departed the UK on time (thankfully – I was getting increasingly bored at the airport). The flight was more or less uneventful. The only exception to that was when the child behind me decided to through a temper tantrum over not getting a toy that was being sold on the Duty Free trolley. This wouldn’t have been so bad had it just been screaming and crying as I could have blocked that out with music/in flight movie. However, as part of her extended temper tantrum she decided to repeatedly kick the back of my chair for over 40 minutes! This was very annoying and the mother refused to do anything about it. Her only response was “what do you expect me to do about it?” I though (and felt like telling her) that maybe a good place to start would be to keep control of her children, but I thought better of it and let the cabin crew deal with it.
We arrived in Toronto 50 minutes early, which was a nice surprise. I cleared immigration without a hitch, which was good. However, I didn’t have the same luck with Customs. I was taken for additional Customs screening (randomly allegedly, but I am sceptical). They asked me loads of questions (repeating the same questions to ensure I gave the same answer) and searched my baggage. I suspect that the fact I am a 20 year old student, travelling alone on a brand new passport might have had something to do with my “random selection”.
So after a trans-Atlantic flight lasting six and a half hours, a very long walk to immigration/customs and the delay at customs; I eventually made it to the arrivals hall where I met my grandparents and we headed off on the three hour journey to their house.
By the time we got to their place it was 21:15 (local time). However, my body was screaming at me trying to tell me to get it bed because it was 02:45. I struggled to stay up for another hour or so to chat to my grandparents, but I had to give in at this point and allow my body to win.
The next few days were not all that interesting. We visited a few small towns along the edges of the lake and I was
constantly battling against my body clock and the horrible jet lag that I was suffering. I’ve been over to Canada several times, but I never remember suffering from jet lag that extreme!
The weather was fairly good over the first few days. There were some spectacular thunder and lightning storms during the later part of the evening of the Tuesday and Wednesday. However, during the day it was worm and sunny – it only hit around 20 Celsius, but that’s a comfortable temperature.
That’s all on my trip just now. The rest will come in subsequent parts over the next week or so. There will also be some photographs for you all to look at as well – just as soon as I get a chance to work my way through the 223 photographs that I’ve taken during my short trip and work out exactly which ones to share with you!
Images in this post are not owned by me.
Blog at WordPress.com. | Theme: Pool by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.

